The period leading up to the publication in July of the Clarke and Kershaw reports and the Council’s immediate response to them has now ended. The Council has accepted the findings and recommendations of the Kershaw report and they seem to have gained widespread general acceptance. Many of the key figures, mainly governors, responsible for the malpractices have resigned, been dismissed or suspended, and it is significant that there is no sign of any call or campaign to reinstate them. A new period now opens up in which the consequences and the causes of the Trojan Horse affair have to be addressed. Birmingham CASE has put together six documents of evidence, analysis and proposals which together represent our contribution.

In Birmingham we summarise the key problem issues and provide supporting evidence, we note the failure of the Council to tackle the problems when they first arose, we highlight the response of the ‘Putting Birmingham school kids first’ campaign, we comment on the recommendations of the Clarke and Kershaw reports and the Council’s own proposals, and offer some of our own for how the community, the schools and the Council can move forward together in a new partnership with a new vision for education. We recognise that the governance and leadership issues which have been identified in East Birmingham are not peculiar to conservative Islam: they can and do occur in many other schools in Birmingham and across the country. We believe that tackling them productively in East Birmingham can provide a catalyst and a model for other areas to do the same.

We also warn of a new danger: the government’s imposition of yet another commissioner, Sir Bob Kerslake, to investigate the Council’s governance could be an opportunity for the government to break up the Council, perhaps into four councils run by an elected mayor.

Nationally the Trojan Horse affair has been used by the government, and in particular by Gove, aided by most of the media, to stigmatise and demonise the Muslim community by promoting a narrative equating Islam in Britain with extremism and links to terrorism. We identify the government policies which have made possible and directly caused the governance malpractices and the government’s subsequent responses which have blown them up into a crisis of Islamophobia.

Their context is two-fold: the racial discrimination which permeates government policies, and the neo-liberal agenda which drives its education policies. The latter include the dictatorial centralised powers of the secretary of state, the disempowerment of local authorities as a result of cuts and academisation, the resulting lack of accountability of school governing bodies, the local autonomy of academies, the abuse of Ofsted as a tool of government policy, the use of the Prevent strategy as a new inspection criterion to fail schools, the use of government-imposed commissioners to control local government, the marginalisation of citizenship education, and the anachronistic obligation of Christian worship in today’s schools.

While the main focus of our response here to Trojan Horse is at the Birmingham level, we stress that its causes and consequences have their roots in national government policy and that is where they have to be relentlessly opposed. There is a heavy responsibility on the Labour leadership to do so, and to give an unequivocal commitment to rescind those policies if elected in 2015.

You can find our full response in the following papers:


 Part 1 The issues

 Part 2 Evidence from five schools

Part 3 Clarke Recommendations and our comments

Part 4 Kershaw Recommendations and our comments

Part 5 Birmingham City Council response

Part 6 Moving forward

We welcome your comments on our response to the Trojan Horse affair. Please use the comment facility or send them to brumcase@gmail.com



2 thoughts on “The Trojan Horse affair and its consequences: a response from Birmingham CASE

  1. Trojan Horse: Involve parents in future of schools, says MP

    The Birmingham Mail reported on 28 August that Hodge Hill MP Liam Byrne has accused the new governors of the Park View Educational Trust, which runs Park View in Alum Rock, Nansen Primary in Saltley, and Golden Hillock, of failing to work with parents to develop a new plan for the schools.

    He told the Mail: “A lot of new as well as existing parents have been worrying about this over the summer and there has not been enough dialogue with them. Parents have not been given a strong enough voice. Now is the time to find a new way of working together.” http://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/trojan-horse-involve-parents-future-7686181

    This is further confirmation of what BCASE says: that it is vital that parents and the community are fully involved in creating the action plans for the schools, not just to get them out of special measures but to create a new vision of education which can take the schools and the community forward together in a new partnership, for which the Children’s Zone approach could provide the framework.

    Richard Hatcher

    PS: There’s a public meeting on ‘Trojan Horse – making opportunities out of adversity’ on 8 September, with Mark Rogers, Chief Executive of Birmingham City Council.


  2. Pingback: Birmingham CASE analysis of ‘Trojan Horse’ affair | SEA News Feed

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s